Alabama’s sales tax holiday is August 5-7, helping
families send the kids back to school. A weekend without sales tax
on clothing, supplies and computers is a big draw for retailers. What
if a store never collected sales tax? Online and mail-order retailers
such as Amazon, Newegg and HSN aren’t required to charge out-of-state
customers. Rather, it’s the consumers’ responsibility to
remit “use tax” on their purchases. The issue is nexus
- if a store doesn’t have a physical presence in a state, it
doesn’t have to charge sales tax. This is why you are charged
4% tax when ordering Moneyball from the Barnes & Noble website
but not from Amazon.

The
rate of collection of use tax is low, as evidenced by the
form letters from the Alabama Department of Revenue which
seek use tax
from residents. Alabama residents are supposed to report
their use tax due on the AL 40 line 19b. The catch is that
states have no actual
idea of the amounts due from taxpayers and rely on
them to report use tax due. Without a consistent manner to
catch violators, 19b often
remains empty.
As
states across the country attempt to expand sources of
revenue, many have turned
to the under-collected use tax and hope to force
retailers to collect sales tax. Efforts have been lukewarm
and results nominal,
but states are pushing forward slowly. California
has been the largest state to pass such a measure (both
North Carolina and Colorado lost
in court). If California’s law lasts, expect
other states to follow suit. Tennessee is being
pressured in the form of a lawsuit from in-state
retail stores to start collecting use tax from
Amazon’s customers. The permanent sales
tax vacation for online retailers
may quickly be coming to a close.